A Clarification of the Relationship Between GDPR and DMA

Authors

  • Gergely Rideg Károli Gáspár University of the Reformed Church in Hungary
  • András Tóth Károli Gáspár University of the Reformed Church in Hungary
  • Endre Győző Szabó Hungarian National Authority for Data Protection and Freedom of Information
  • Szabolcs Németh National Film Institute Hungary
  • Regina Rudics Károli Gáspár University of the Reformed Church in Hungary

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.59851/imr.12.2.3

Keywords:

DMA, GDPR, data protection, digitalisation, data portability

Abstract

The Digital Markets Act is a new piece of EU legislation that builds on existing EU legislation, including the General Data Protection Regulation, to target regulation of tech giants. While the protection of personal data and privacy at a fundamental rights level used to be the cornerstone of EU regulation, the EU has now also made it a priority to exploit the benefits of a data-driven economy and to increase the competitiveness of European markets. In this paper, we highlight the points of the Digital Markets Act, Digital Services Actand General Data Protection Regulation whose interplay will be crucial for the future development of a competitive and data-driven European economy. We will examine the primacy of the General Data Protection Regulation, its possible lex specialis nature, and the prohibitions introduced by the Digital Markets Act, such as the prohibition to use business users’ and/or own consumers’ data for private purposes, or the prohibition to combine user data from different services of the platform. Finally, we will discuss the relationship between the Digital Markets Act and the preservation of the European data assets.

References

Apostle, Julia: The EU’s Digital Markets Act: What Does It Mean for Businesses and Data Privacy? Orrick, 2022. november 1., https://bit.ly/3RbJUUF.

Bania, Konstantina: Fitting the Digital Markets Act in the Existing Legal Framework: The Myth of the „Without Prejudice” Clause. 19(1) European Competition Journal (2022) 116–149., https://doi.org/10.1080/17441056.2022.2156730 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/17441056.2022.2156730

Belloso, N. Moreno – Petit, Nicolas: The EU Digital Markets Act (DMA): A Competition Hand in a Regulatory Glove. European Law Review, 2023. április 19.,

https://bit.ly/3QTBX59.

Bendiek, Annegret: Integrationspolitische Bedeutung des Digital Service Act (DSA) und Digital Markets Act (DMA). Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik, 2021. március 1., https://bit.ly/47Mc3HC.

Botta, Marco – Wiedemann, Klaus: Exploitative Conducts in Digital Markets: Time for a Discussion after the Facebook Decision. 10(8) Journal of European Competition Law & Practice (2019) 465–478., https://doi.org/10.1093/jeclap/lpz064 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/jeclap/lpz064

Bundeskartellamt Prohibits Facebook from Combining User Data from Different Sources, 2019, https://bit.ly/46u3LTI.

Buttarelli, Giovani: Opinion 4/2017 of the European Data Protection Supervisor, https://bit.ly/47qKDY0.

Candelon, François – Reeves, Martin: The New Digital World: Hegemony or Harmony? BCG, 2017. november 14., https://on.bcg.com/47lK7dI.

Carugati, Christophe: How to implement the self-preferencing ban in the European Union’s Digital Markets Act. Bruegel, 2022. december 2., https://bit.ly/47LjRct.

Ennis, Sean F. – Evans, Ben: Cloud Portability and Interoperability under the EU Data Act: Dynamism Versus Equivalence. SSRN, 2023. március 22., https://bit.ly/3t51yAf. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4395183

Evans, David S.: The Economics of Attention Markets, https://bit.ly/49RSy1W.

Fleming, Sean: What is Digital Sovereignty and Why is Europe So Interested in it? World Economic Forum, 2021. március 15., https://bit.ly/47ogGI3.

Geradin, Damien – Bania, Konstantina – Karanikioti, Theano: The Interplay between the Digital Markets Act and the General Data Protection Regulation. 2022, https://bit.ly/3SOPJc5. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4203907

Hacker, Philipp – Cordes, Johann – Rochon, Janina: Regulating Gatekeeper AI and Data: Transparency, Access and Fairness under the DMA, the GDPR and Beyond, https://bit.ly/3MVNOyy.

Heinemann, Andreas – Meier, Giulia M.: Der Digital Markets Act (DMA): Neues „Plattformrecht” für mehr Wettbewerb in der digitalen Wirtschaft. Zeitschrift für Europarecht, 2021, 86–101.

Hennemann, Moritz et al.: The Data Act Proposal: Literature Review and Critical Analysis, Part I. Passau, University of Passau, 2023.

Hoofnagle, Chris Jay – Whittington, Jan: „Free: Accounting for the Costs of the Internet’s Most Popular Price” 61(3) UCLA Law Review (2014) 606–670.

Investigation into Google’s ‘Privacy Sandbox’ browser changes. Competition and Markets Authority, 2021. január 8., https://bit.ly/3RcifTP.

Kelber, Ulrich: EU-Digitalstrategie und die dazugehörigen Rechtsakte von DGA, DMA, DSA und AIA – Auswirkungen für den Datenschutz. Bundesbeauftragten für den Datenschutz und die Informationsfreiheit, 2022. január 27., https://bit.ly/47O22cH.

Stolton, Samuel: LEAK: Commission in Bid for EU Data Sovereignty with Digital Decade Targets. Euractive, 2021. március 8., https://bit.ly/46InNtT.

The World’s Most Valuable Resource Is No Longer Oil, but Data. The Economist, 2017. május 6., https://econ.st/47rUw7R.

Tóth András: A mesterséges intelligencia szabályozásának paradoxonja és egyes jogi vonatkozásainak alapvető kérdései. Infokommunikáció és Jog, 2019/2., 3–9., https://bit.ly/46KlZAe.

VBL-Gegenwert II., Hintergrundinformationen zum Facebook-Verfahren des Bundeskartellamtes, 2017, https://bit.ly/49ILNQh.

Verfahren gegen US-Konzern. EU wirft Amazon Kartellverstöße vor. Tagesschau, 2020. november 10, https://bit.ly/3sLqL2z.

Vergnolle, Suzanne: Enforcement of the DSA and the DMA: What did We Learn from the GDPR? Hal Open Science, https://bit.ly/49H6bky.

Wils, Wouter P. J.: The Obligation for the Competition Authorities of the EU Member States to Apply EU Antitrust Law and the Facebook Decision of the Bundeskartellamt. London, King’s College London Law School, 2019. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3424592

Witt, Anne C.: The Digital Markets Act: Regulating the Wild West. (60)3 Common Market Law Review (2023) 625–666. DOI: https://doi.org/10.54648/COLA2023047

Wu, Tim: Blind Spot: The Attention Economy and the Law. Antitrust Law Journal, vol. 82., https://bit.ly/3uHJj4z.

Zimmermann, Hendrik – Heinzel, Caroline: Der Digital Markets Act. Plattform-Regulierung für Demokratie und Nachhaltigkeit in der EU–aktueller Stand und Verbesse-rungspotenziale, Germanwatch, 2022. január, https://bit.ly/3GaQogo.

Published

14-12-2023

How to Cite

Rideg, G., Tóth, A., Szabó, E. G., Németh, S., & Rudics, R. (2023). A Clarification of the Relationship Between GDPR and DMA. In Medias Res, 12(2), 45–68. https://doi.org/10.59851/imr.12.2.3

Issue

Section

Articles